321102 179394602137508 100002009078427 363358 727551657 n-1-.jpg This page is one of a group called

Puzzles Home Page
Classic Five-Hat Problem (Answer)
Oil and Vinegar Problem (Answer)
Game Show Problem (Answer)

It is definitely in the contestant's interest to change their choice. At the first stage they have only a one in three chance of winning, but if they change their choice at the second stage they have a two in three chance. If the contestant has chosen an empty box at the first stage, the host has no choice as to which box he opens at the second stage, and so the remaining box will always contain the money.

The table below shows the outcomes in each of the eighteen possible cases. Work through them all if you wish.

(If you are viewing on a mobile phone, you might find you need to scroll down a bit to a screenshot from another site.)

Money in 1st choice Stay put Change
**Box A **Box A **Win **Lose
**Box A **Box B **Lose **Win
**Box A **Box C **Lose **Win
**Box B **Box A **Lose **Win
**Box B **Box B **Win **Lose
**Box B **Box C **Lose **Win
**Box C **Box A **Lose **Win
**Box C **Box B **Lose **Win
**Box C **Box C **Win **Lose

Here is the screenshot:
Game show puzzle outcomes

Back to the question.

Back to Puzzles.